Lake Whitefish

Common Name Lake Whitefish
Market Name inland whitefish, shad
Scientific name Coregonus clupeaformis
107

Sourcing Summary

Size

1.5-3.0 lbs.

Lake whitefish are available fresh and frozen whole, in fillets, and as steaks. Value-added lake whitefish are sold as roe or smoked, either head-on or in fillets. When raw, the flesh will be nearly pure white and then turns off-white when cooked. Lake whitefish have high fat content and a mild flavor with medium-firm meat that has large flakes. The high fat content makes this fish ideal for smoking. When sourcing lake whitefish, both the lake and the specific state/province information is important to note. 

Lake Whitefish Sustainability

Based on average landings of lake whitefish from 2014-2016 and using the most recent 2014 Seafood Watch report, the sustainability breakdown of lake whitefish is as follows:

  • ~5% of total lake whitefish landings meet a Seafood Watch "Best Choice (green)" rating (from Lake Michigan in Wisconsin)
  • ~50% of total lake whitefish landings meet a Seafood Watch "Good Alternative (yellow)" rating (by lakes, ~50% comes from Lake Huron and ~25% each from Lake Michigan and Lake Superior; by state/province, ~65% from Michigan and ~35% from Ontario)
  • ~5% of total lake whitefish landings meet a Seafood Watch "Avoid (red)" rating (from Lake Superior in Wisconsin)
  • ~40% of total lake whitefish landings are unknown/unrated
  • Lake white from Lake Michigan is ~1/3 Best Choice and ~2/3 Good Alternative 
  • Lake whitefish from Lake Superior is ~70% Good Alternative and ~30% Avoid
  • Lake whitefish from Wisconsin is ~55% Best Choice* and ~45% Avoid
  • Less than 3% of lake whitefish landings come from Lakes Erie and Ontario and <1% comes from Ohio
  • Total lake whitefish landings in 2016 to 2014 saw a slight increase but decreased ~10% compared to 2012

Product Forms

Fresh/Frozen
Fresh
Product Forms
Fillet
Head-on
Steaks
Whole
Fresh/Frozen
Frozen
Product Forms
Fillet
Head-on
Steaks
Whole

Fresh Seasonal Availability

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
nononoyesyesyesyesyesyesyesnono

Culinary Composition

Flavor

Mild

Texture

Medium

Health/Nutrition

Nutrition facts

Serving Size: 100g
Amount per serving
Calories 134
Total Fat 5.9g
Cholesterol 48mg
Sodium 51mg
Carbohydrates 0g
Protein 19.1g

Biology

Lake whitefish are a slender, elongated species with a nose that protrudes over their mouth. They are silver with a light green-brown back. Their tail is deeply forked and they have an adipose fin that helps stabilize the fish while swimming. Their fins are white and their tail is dark along its edges. Lake whitefish usually grow to about 1.5 to two feet in length and can weigh up to four pounds. The maximum recorded age of a lake whitefish is 50 years, but most individuals have a lifespan of around 25 years.

Lake whitefish become sexually mature at around four to seven years of age. They breed once a year; spawning in the late fall into December when water falls below 45 degrees Fahrenheit (seven degrees Celsius). Spawning usually occurs close to the shore or around islands. During spawning, females will release 10,000-130,000 eggs (depending on their size) and males will simultaneously release their sperm into the water. The fertilized eggs will fall to the bottom of the lake and settle there – hatching in early spring.

Juvenile lake whitefish feed on zooplankton and begin to eat insect larvae as they grow. Adult whitefish will eat amphipods, clams, snails, shrimp, larvae, and small fish. Small lake whitefish are preyed upon by lake trout, salmon, northern pike, walleye, and burbot. Invasive sea lampreys are one of their main predators as adults.

Species Habitat

Lake whitefish are widely distributed in North America – ranging throughout northern New England, the Great Lakes, and westward to British Columbia, the Yukon, and Alaska. They have also been introduced to Montana, Idaho, and Washington State. Lake Whitefish are benthic and occupy deep, cold, well-oxygenated lakes and large rivers. They can occupy depths of up to 200 feet (61 meters) and have also been known to enter brackish water. Generally found in schools, lake whitefish spawn in the late fall in shallow waters less than 25 feet deep (eight meters) over rocky and sandy bottoms.

Science & Management

Wild
Science

Current research led by Michigan State University and Michigan Sea Grant is focused on how climate factors can influence recruitment of lake whitefish and how commercial fisheries can adapt to climate change. Climate change is expected to raise the surface temperatures of the Great Lakes with warmer spring waters potentially increasing plankton productivity and providing greater food availability for lake whitefish larvae – which could lead to higher survival rates. On the other hand, increases in fall temperatures could result in increased storm events and less ice cover that may inhibit the egg survival of lake whitefish.

Management

As the Great Lakes encompass two countries, multiple states, one province, and a number of tribal lands, management of lake whitefish is complex. To address coordination and shared management of the resource, the United States, and Canadian governments formed the Great Lakes Fishery Commission (GLFC) in 1954. The GLFC consist of four Canadian and four American commissioners who are appointed by their governments and supported by a secretariat in Ann Arbor, Michigan. In 1981, the GLFC enacted the non-binding Joint Strategic Plan for Management of Great Lakes Fisheries that has been subsequently reviewed in 1986 and amended in 1997 in an effort to better coordinate fishery and environmental management issues in the Great Lakes.

Within the GLFC, each Great Lake has its own Lake Committee that is made up of state, provincial, and tribal representatives of the actual fishery management bodies for that lake (with additional support by various federal agencies). The GLFC and Lake Committees are not responsible for day-to-day fishery management, but rather serve as a platform to bring together multiple agencies involved in Great Lakes fisheries to better coordinate research, enforcement, stocking, quotas, and to address other fishery issues. Lake Committees were first established by the GLFC in 1965 as the mechanism for individual agencies to share information; however, it was only after the 1981 Joint Strategic Plan that these Committees became tasked with establishing fishery management goals (called Fish Community Objectives) for each lake and to set agreed-upon yearly harvest levels. They also produce a “state-of-the-lake” report every five years to summarize fishery trends and status. Lake Committees are supported by Technical Committees, which conduct stock assessments and collect fishery data, interpret science, and then make management recommendations to the Lake Committee. Any management objectives that the Lake Committees agree-upon are implemented and managed by the individual state, provincial, or tribal agencies – usually by that state’s Department of Natural Resources (DNRs). These agencies are ultimately responsible for the day-to-day management of the fishery and are responsible for issuing fishing licenses, determining harvest levels, as well as for carrying out other management actions such as establishing size, gear, and area restrictions. DNRs, as well as federal agencies like the US Coast Guard, carry out on-water and on-dock inspections and enforce management measures.

Harvest Methods

Conservation Criteria - Wild

Impact on Stock

Lake whitefish are a freshwater fish related to salmon and trout that come from the Great Lakes in the United States and Canada. During the first half of the 20th century, whitefish were in decline from industrial pressure, habitat loss, contamination, and overfishing. Management measures introduced in the 1950s expanded over time and, as a result, Great Lakes whitefish have mostly recovered.

However, Seafood Watch gave whitefish in Lake Superior in Wisconsin an “avoid” rating due to lack of commercial harvest information as well as data suggesting that stock may be declining. The Lake Erie fishery received a high concern rating for abundance because independent surveys indicated that recruitment rates appear low. Whitefish populations in eastern Lake Superior have been declining due to overfishing and Seafood Watch reported that unlicensed fishing is happening in this area.

Habitat impacts (Wild)

Whitefish are caught with trap nets and bottom gillnets throughout the Great Lakes. Lake bottoms have soft substrates consisting of sand, silt and muck. The impact of trapnets on the areas where they are used is considered negligible. Bottom gillnets also have a low impact limited to anchors that cause minimal amounts of scouring during setting and hauling, Seafood Watch reported.

Bycatch

Generally the impacts of bycatch in Great Lakes whitefish fisheries are considered low due to the placement of gear and size restrictions on it. Lake sturgeon landings are prohibited because of their status as endangered or threatened in the Great Lakes. Although some do get caught unintentionally in gillnets used to target lake whitefish, scientists and fishermen found that most are returned to the water alive so there is no significant impact. Lake trout is also threatened and cannot be sold portside, but the amount of this bycatch in the whitefish fishery overall is low.

Management effectiveness

Lake whitefish has a patchy distribution and stocks that intermingle, which makes assessment and management complex. In addition, the Great Lakes span multiple countries and jurisdictions. The Great Lakes Fishery Commission (GLFC) is an international agency covering multiple jurisdictions that coordinates fishery management. Separate lake commissions within the GLFC conduct scientific research and make lake-specific management recommendations. Whitefish scientific research and monitoring in the Great Lakes is highly effective. Complete and robust scientific stock assessments are carried out on a regular basis. Seafood Watch noted that lake trout is a species of concern and it’s unclear when the population will reach management goals for recovery. In general, however, recent Seafood Watch reports found lake whitefish management to be effective. 

Conservation Criteria - Farmed

Origin Method Ratings
Canada - Lake Erie Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Huron Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Manitoba Midwater Gillnet  
Canada - Lake of the Woods Bottom Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Ontario Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Simcoe & Mora River Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Simcoe & Mora River Trap Net  
Canada - Lake Superior Gillnet  
Canada - Shoal Lake Bottom Gillnet  
Canada - Winnipeg River Bottom Gillnet  
Unassessed Origin Unassessed Fishing Methods  
USA - Lake Erie (Michigan) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Erie (Ohio) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Huron Gillnet  
USA - Lake Huron Trap Net  
USA - Lake Michigan (Michigan) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Michigan (Michigan) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Michigan (Wisconsin) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Michigan (Wisconsin) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Superior (Michigan) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Superior (Michigan) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Superior (Wisconsin) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Superior (Wisconsin) Trap Net  

Rating From Seafood Species Relationship

Origin Method Ratings
Canada - Lake Erie Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Huron Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Manitoba Midwater Gillnet  
Canada - Lake of the Woods Bottom Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Ontario Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Simcoe & Mora River Gillnet  
Canada - Lake Simcoe & Mora River Trap Net  
Canada - Lake Superior Gillnet  
Canada - Shoal Lake Bottom Gillnet  
Canada - Winnipeg River Bottom Gillnet  
Unassessed Origin Unassessed Fishing Methods  
USA - Lake Erie (Michigan) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Erie (Ohio) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Huron Gillnet  
USA - Lake Huron Trap Net  
USA - Lake Michigan (Michigan) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Michigan (Michigan) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Michigan (Wisconsin) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Michigan (Wisconsin) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Superior (Michigan) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Superior (Michigan) Trap Net  
USA - Lake Superior (Wisconsin) Gillnet  
USA - Lake Superior (Wisconsin) Trap Net  
Name Country State / Province
Allseas Fisheries Corp. Canada Ontario
Bay Port Fish Company United States Michigan
Carlson's of Fishtown United States Michigan
Catanese Classic Seafood United States Ohio
Daily Seafood Inc. Canada Ontario
Dockside Fish Market United States Minnesota
Euclid Fish Company United States Ohio
Export Packers Company Limited Canada Ontario
John Nagle Co. United States Massachusetts
Lusamerica Foods, Inc. United States California
Macgregors Meat & Seafood Ltd. Canada Ontario
Mackinac Straits Fish Company United States Michigan
Profish Ltd. United States District of Columbia
Ruleau Brothers, Inc. United States Michigan
Seacore Seafood Inc. Canada Ontario
Seattle Fish Company United States Colorado
Seattle Fish Company - Kansas City United States Missouri
Susie Q Fish Market United States Wisconsin
The Fish Guys Inc. United States Minnesota
The Fresh Lake Whitefish Company United States Michigan